The other day, I was hacking away on the PHP backend for the “Startup Institute” visualization and I realized it was going to need a good deal of array manipulation. Figuring it was as good a time as any, I decided to try and leverage PHP 5.3+ new closures along with the array_* functions to manipulate the arrays. I’m not well versed with functional programming but I’ve used Underscore.js’s array/collection functions so this is mostly in comparison to that.
The entire shebang is on GitHub but here is the gist of what we’re intersted in:
There is a CSV file that looks like ssdata.csv.sample except with more entries that is read into a list ($data) where every object has keys cooresponding to the values in the header. Thinking in JSON, the array ends up looking like:
Ok great, but now what can we do with it?
Using the usort function is particularly natural with closures. Compare the following:
It’s pretty clear the version with closures is much shorter, more conscience, and ultimately easier to follow. Being able to “capture” the local $sortKey variable is also a key feature on the closure version since with the static version there’s no easy way to introduce variables into the sorting function.
In the linked example, I used array_map to basically convert an array of characters into an array of ASCII values for those characters.
With such a small map function, it’s hard to see or appreciate the benefits of using the closure along with array_map. With the closure though, you’ll get a couple of benefits including isolated scope so that you won’t inadvertently rely on the value of a variable that isn’t directly related to transforming the array values.
Using the closure would also “look” much cleaner if the array had non-numeric keys, since without being able to use integer indexes the for(…) loop would be more confusing.
This isn’t used but it could have been to return only the elements that were selected.
Looking at the the version with the closure, its a bit easier to follow and since it’ll enforce scope isolation if the “truth test” was a bit more complicated you’d only have to debug what’s actually inside the closure. Also, not having to “skip” some elements leaves the code with a nicer feel and overall I’d argue its just better looking.
Overall, using closures with the array_* functions will definitely lead to cleaner, more concise, and easier to follow code. Unfortunately, there are a few rough spots. Like with most of the standard library, the argument order is inconsistent which is always a constant irritation. For example, for no apparent reason array_map is “callback, array” but array_filter is “array, callback”. Also, another irritation is that the “index” isn’t available inside several of the callbacks like on array_reduce or array_map.
Personally though, the biggest limitation is that none of the array_* functions will work with classes that implement the Traversable or Iterator interfaces. That means if you have a Doctrine_Collection and you want to reduce down to a single result you’re still stuck with a foreach(…).
Anyway, as always I’d love to hear other opinions in the comments.
Posted In: PHP, Tips n' Tricks